Home » Course Review

Eagle Landing at Oakleaf Plantation is a playable playground south of Jacksonville, Florida

By Jason Scott Deegan, Senior Staff Writer

ORANGE PARK, Fla. -- Architect Clyde Johnston built just enough unique features on Eagle Landing at Oakleaf Plantation to stand out among the best golf courses on the south side of Jacksonville.

Eagle Landing at Oakleaf Plantation
Clyde Johnston designed the Eagle Landing golf course in 2006.
Eagle Landing at Oakleaf PlantationEagle Landing at Oakleaf Plantation - hole 18Eagle Landing at Oakleaf Plantation - clubhouse

Johnston, who has designed three other courses in greater Jacksonville, incorporated a waterfall, a church-pew bunker and bookend par 4s around the same pond to finish each nine. More than anything, those who play Eagle Landing will likely remember their score more than any particular hole. Johnston deserves kudos for designing a 7,037-yard layout that rewards good shots and doesn't devour bad ones. Weekend warriors tend to miss their fair share of shots. Johnston gives them enough room for second and third chances.

There are six sets of tees, which is more than most clubs. Men can play from 6,764 yards on the blues or the 6,359-yard whites. The 5,894-yard green tees cater to longer-hitting ladies, senior men or high-handicappers. There are even yellow youth tees, perfect for the beginner, at 2,789 yards.

"People like Eagle Landing for its playability. It's fair," said Tim Spangler, the director of golf at Eagle Landing. "It is usually in good condition. Golf today is such a luxury item. The last thing you want to do is shoot 120 and lose lots of golf balls."

Eagle Landing's "linksy feel"

Johnston, a fan of classic architecture, built a course that delivers a linksy feel with wide, fast fairways and big greens. Players can bounce shots up onto the greens and putt balls that just miss around the edges. Water remains a factor on only five holes, especially at Nos. 9 and 18 and the par 3s at Nos. 6 and 16.

Johnston's par-5 holes stand out. The 600-yard seventh is the No. 1 handicap thanks to an intimidating pond guarding the left side off the tee. The 10th bends left with a green that is reachable in two. Just don't miss long. The back of the putting surface slopes into the waterfall visible on the drive into the subdivision. This is Spangler's favorite spot on the course.

"Every hole should have a waterfall," he said. "It's just so soothing."

A massive bunker with six grassy humps called church pews, a tribute to the famous Oakmont Country Club in Pennsylvania, tends to gather up loose tee shots on the par-5 17th. Spangler said Johnston had to take out a few pews before the course opened to soften the penalty for landing there.

"It's so big. The players hate it," Spangler said.

That's not entirely true. Sometimes, the golf gods allow safe passage through the pews. David Bammer, a regular customer who visits from Michigan, lauds its design, even if he's had to wedge it out a time or two.

"For such a short par 5, that's a great feature," Bammer said.

Eagle Landing at Oakleaf Plantation: The verdict

It was no coincidence I shot my lowest score of the four rounds I played in and around Jacksonville at Eagle Landing. All my drives rolled out farther because of the firm conditions and the green complexes weren't overly penal. It's a golf course that strikes a great balance between providing enough challenge to make it interesting, while staying fair.

Jason Scott DeeganJason Scott Deegan, Senior Staff Writer

Jason Scott Deegan has reviewed more than 700 courses and golf destinations for some of the industry's biggest publications. His work has been honored by the Golf Writer's Association of America and the Michigan Press Association. Follow him on Twitter at @WorldGolfer.

Reader Comments / Reviews Leave a comment
Jacksonville Beach Golf Packages
Dates: August 14, 2017 - June 30, 2018
Let your golf escape to Jacksonville begin at DoubleTree by Hilton Riverfront, fresh from an extensive renovation and featuring a unique riverfront location. While staying at Doubletree, golfers will enjoy walkout balconies with stunning views, a riverfront pool and verandah.
Price range: $349