Attention: LPGA, PGA, USGA: Boys Should Be Boys, But Girls Can Play, Too.
A poor young man failed in his attempt to sue a school district for the right to compete as a male on a female interscholastic athletic team. This hearkens back to Brian Kontak’s bragadaccio about participating in the US Women’s Open with his wee-wee intact. May I speak for all of society when I write that I am fed up with this polemic?
Competition is all about defeating the better opponent. When you conquer one level, you move on. For a male to compete against females in most sports, the point is moot. I have read quotes from Annika Sorenstam on her tutelage by Tiger Woods, and what she has learned from him. The reverse, however, I have not read. Interpretation: He knows more than she and is better.
For a woman to aspire, a la Michelle Wie, to compete against men, is not a foolish thing. It should not be dismissed. It is a simple case of survival of the fittest, where a lesser opponent strives to better herself by competing against stronger competition. That gender is involved is both unimportant and coincidental.
For a person to intentionally compete against women or men of lesser ability is ridiculous, unless an equalizing agent (read: handicap strokes) is involved. In Kontak’s case, his performances on the Canadian and Nationwide tours would rate him as superior to the competitors in the US Women’s Open. He would be a longer driver of the ball, a better putter, and a more accurate iron player. Unless he had nerves of pasta, he would win the US Women’s Open.
What about Kevin Na competing on the Nationwide Tour (and winning) at the MCCCPBCOSB? Simple. Na was rehabbing an injury, against players who aspire to (and are darn close to) compete against him on the PGA Tour. Non-issue.
Let Michelle Wie compete against the men as long as she wishes. Whether you don’t support her quest, don’t support her quest, or know better than her family, she has the right on this spinning orb to compete against those who are better.
| « LPGA versus PGA Tour: Can women be as diverse as men? | LPGA Tour Qualifying School...Get REAL, as in Real-Time Scoring » |
21 comments
Until your daugther can command 875K for 2 days of work (with two optional days), please refrain from critiquing Wie's parents' decision.
I would love to play against the best possible competition, but I'm not good enough, neither is Michelle.
shot a 68 at the Q school yesterday?
Let's stay focused on important events.
Mucus, AMEN, BROTHER! Bowditch is on his way to the President's Cup. And admit it, you've taken a shine to him.
Ron Mon for a guy who looks an awful lot like a ferret you sure are arrogant, no wonder you like Michelle. This is probably what Judge was looking for...I thought I would add a few more Michelle quotes just in case your memory was still hazy. Michelle is arrogant, hypocritical and at this point just plain delusional about her future. I could have gathered these excuse laden quotes all day.
"I don't think I would say I don't belong here; I do belong. I belong on the LPGA; I belong on the PGA (TOUR). I think I belong in both." - following her performance at the 2004 Sony Open
"Ty Tryon made a lot of money after turning pro, but he might not have been ready. I don't want to make a lot of money for a couple of months and then not be ready." - on her willingness to wait to turn pro (from Business Week)
”I think my ultimate goal is to play in the Masters. I think it'd be pretty neat walking down the Masters fairways,” says Wie, who thinks the world is ready for it.
What does she say those who are skeptical of her ability to compete with men in professional golf? “I think the reason they're saying that is because they're truly afraid. I mean, men's egos can be easily brought down, and I don't think they want that to happen,” says Michelle. “I have some experience with my dad, and I think that it’s just the way guys are.”
"Not at all," said Wie, winless in 33 career LPGA Tour appearances. "I didn't play like myself today and it doesn't bother me because I know I can play much better than this. I learn a lot from playing with the men."
"I felt like from tee to green I played very well. My short game and putting let me down a couple of times -- every time," Wie said. "It doesn't feel like I played 5-over because I hit the ball really good."
"But I feel a lot more confident and comfortable with my game," she said. "I'm hitting my irons 10 yards longer than I did last week. I think I could have easily shot under par today, but my putts didn't go in and I feel they will go in tomorrow."
"I just had a bad two weeks, that's it. No more, no less," she said, brushing off the suggestion that she might want to reconsider her goal of playing against the men. "I feel like I'm getting better and better even though my scores don't show it. My game is progressing. My shots are actually going to the fairway now. I felt like my game was 100 times better than last week."
"I just feel like I have to work on my putting a little bit," she said. "I'm not saying I'm ever going to be the No. 1 distance driver, but I feel like I can definitely be average or above average. I definitely feel like if I work out more, if I increase my stamina, I feel like I definitely have potential because of my height and the power that I have."
"You're hitting, like, a 5-iron or 4-iron to the hole. You don't have a wedge in your hand like at a women's event," she said. "I think the length will definitely motivate me to work out a lot harder because I definitely see potential in gaining a lot more distance. Obviously, everyone knows my ultimate goal is to play in the Masters, but right now I'm really enjoying competing with the guys."
"I have a lot more to improve but I definitely think I can win out there (on the PGA Tour) one of these years."
"If I ever get bored with golf, I'm going to start over and play lefthanded."
“My favorite player is Tiger Woods. I think I can beat Tiger when I’m 20. It’s a life goal.”
“I might go play the LPGA full-time and then, after I get better, go to the PGA full-time. Or just try to play both. It will be fun.”
“I might go play the LPGA full-time and then, after I get better, go to the PGA full-time. Or just try to play both. It will be fun.”
By tghe age of thirteen she was already discounting the LPGA tour and planning for her future on the PGA tour. 0 wins, 0 cuts made on any major male tour, with a scoring average hovering around your avergage 6 handicapper
its time to scale back your unrealistic goals.
NYC...Here is the only quote where she goes directly after men, and only re: our egos. Never does she say her abilities are better than those of the men. YOU FAIL TO PROVE YOUR POINT.
To have a comprehensive compilation of Wie's quotes, you must be a secret admirere of Wie.
Are you sure you don't want to rethink that??
Baby Blues--It's not that hard to find juicy Wie quotes, just google "Michelle Wie fails to make the cut at..." and just insert any tournament you want. I am not a fan or even really a basher. I just don't like when "journalists" such as Ron Mon practice selective memory. Michelle's fans are even worse...I have seen where some are actually attempting to cast Michelle as an underdog and someone whose performance has matched her hype. Maybe next week I will post some of the quotes that those in the golf world have attributed to Michelle. Let me put it this way the general consensous was that it was a given that she would be able to make it on the PGA tour(not make cuts, but actually be able to win). The LPGA tour well that was a mere stepping stone, hardly worthy of her time. I am simply pointing out for the few who dared to question her future domination how right we were. In other words, a big "I told you so!" to all the suck ups, feminists, and PC wimps that annointed Michelle Wie to demi-god status before she had ever accomplished anything of note.
The sports world is littered with the remains of child prodigies, can't miss superstars and kids who peaked too early. Will Michelle wind up alongside them on the side of the road--who knows, but I think it is safe to say that she won't be revolutionizing the game any time soon.
a journalist. NYC is right about Wie, though.
Those quotes are hysterical, coming from
anyone. No excuses for her being a kid;
she's a "professional" after all.
Excellent quotations. Yes, we naysayers were right about Bubbles, but these Wiemen stand by their guns as tenaciously as the Japanese did during WWII. And for Ron Mon to be unaware of her braggadocio is unbelievable, given that he's a golf blogger.
Hey, Ronnie, with the limited knowledge base you seem to possess and your ability to view matters through the a prism, you may yet have a career ahead of you in the mainstream media.
NYC,
I was raised in NYC myself.
Exhibit B: I don't want to make a lot of money for a couple of months and then not be ready.
Exhibit C: I think the length will definitely motivate me to work out a lot harder because I definitely see potential in gaining a lot more distance.
Exhibit D: Or just try to play both. It will be fun.
Oedipus, Antigone, Lear, MacBeth, Cleopatra, Wie...All done in by hubris. These four transparent quotes from Wie, thanks to NYC, show that Wie is within the throes of hubris, and will meet an untimely, tragic end. ARE YOU GUYS INSANE?!?!?! The differences between you and she are that A) she MUST talk about her daily performance, whereas you chumps hide away in your cubicles, covering up your daily failings; B) she gives evidence that she is truly interested in improvement (granted, she hasn't shown much of it lately)...when was the last time you payasos took a continuing education course, attended a professional workshop, or signed up for a golf lesson? Keep it coming, boys, I'm more than a match for any and all of you!
I wish Michelle all the best in her future endeavors, but I won't gloss over the facts regarding her rise or fall.


Recent comments