TravelGolf.com
- Updated Daily |
Golf Search
-
Course ReviewsCourse GuideResort FeaturesTravel FeaturesGolf InstructionGolf PackagersReader Forums
The Daily Blog Archives
Ron Mon   Ron Mon
   a TravelGolf.com Blog
-
Blog Home | The Daily Blog | Worldwide Golf Blogs | Free Golf Podcasts

Hypocrisy of USGA Walker Cup selection committee

Tuesday August 28, 2007 | 09:18:37 374 words, 2381 views
Win a free golf book!

Now that I’ve slept on it, I have a clearer vision of the USGA Walker Cup selection committee’s hypocrisy. Here’s what we had to perceive as their premise: we value our own Amateur championship so little that we will only hold out two spots based on its results. The irony is, the player that stepped up and played out of his gourd to reach the final, did not make the team. Let’s take a look at Rickie Fowler versus Michael Thompson.

Fowler came to the final nine of his qualifier well within the number…and shot five-over par for that stretch. He bogeyed four of his final six holes to fall into the qualifying playoff, where he promptly made five to depart after one single hole. That’s the type of pressure player I want on my side. The USGA gave him a chance, and he blew it.

Contrast Fowler’s performance with that of Thompson. The University of Alabama senior played his final nine holes in one-under fashion, six strokes better than the Oklahoma State freshman. He made three birdies, including one on 18, and two bogeys down the stretch. In round one of match play, he defeated Walker Cup player Webb Simpson by going -5 for the fifteen holes of the match. In round two, he faltered a bit but escaped, playing +3 golf over 20 holes against Bryce Ledford. Round three was the same, +3 over 17 holes of a 2&1 victory over David McDaniel. The quarters broughtTh a derailment of the D-Train, the hottest player to that point in match play (Derek Fathaue) with an even-par performance through fifteen holes. A semifinal victory at +1 brought him to the finals, where he faced his second Walker Cupper in Colt Knost. Through 35 holes, Thompson played +8, which may have been his undoing. Knost was a bit better in a medal context, at +4.

It seems that the USGA set the table for a highly-ranked player to make the team, then canceled the menu. Fowler did everything wrong while Thompson did everything right, then the table was turned. If anything, this should make us feel better about our selves. The knowledge that people of power and respect make incredulous decisions might serve to legitimate our own places in the hierarchy of the world.

Comments:

Comment from: Shanks [Member] Email · http://www.travelgolf.com/blogs/shanks
On the other hand, do you want to base your decision on just a single 9-hole score or the whole year? The kid hit a bad patch. It happens.
Permalink 08/28/07 @ 11:09
Comment from: Ron Mon [Member] Email
Well, I must be basing too much on the Porter cup, where Fowler was average, finishing T-26 against a defenseless course without rough. He qualified third the next week at the Western, the toughest event on the schedule, and lost in the quarters. When you have two equally-qualified players, you have to make a tough decision. Imagine how tough that smoke-filled room was!
Permalink 08/28/07 @ 13:30
Comment from: Shanks [Member] Email · http://www.travelgolf.com/blogs/shanks
Will be a little interesting side story to follow, just like the Ryder & President Cup Captain's picks always are.
Permalink 08/28/07 @ 15:03
Comment from: Wounded Duck [Visitor] Email · http://www.woundedquacker.blogspot.com
Sports can't always be boiled down to stats--sometimes you just have to go with your gut.
Permalink 08/28/07 @ 21:22
Comment from: Ron Mon [Member] Email
True enough. Especially when the two finalists were as close as Fowler and Thompson.
Permalink 08/28/07 @ 21:56
Comment from: Oui Oui Oui [Visitor] Email
When the Democrats take office next year, the Walker Cup will be renamed the Jefferson Cup...
Permalink 08/29/07 @ 08:35
Comment from: Ron Mon [Member] Email
How about the Clinton Cup? I did not play golf with that woman! Or, the Rove Cup? Or the Gonzalez Cup?
Permalink 08/29/07 @ 09:30

Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.

Allowed XHTML tags: <p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small>. Bloggers reserve the right to edit or delete comments. Any opinions expressed above are those of the writer and do not necessarily represent the views of the management.
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email and url)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will NOT be displayed.))
Grass is green. What color is grass?
-

Misc

GolfPublisher.com Add GolfPublisher.com articles/headlines to your web site
Course Reviews | US Golf Guide | Resort Features | Travel Features | Golf Instruction | Golf Schools | Golf Packages | Free Vacation Quote

© Copyright 1997-2008, WorldGolf.com, LLC. For questions, comments or suggestions on any of our network publications, Contact Us!
Privacy Policy