« Tiger Woods is Grabbing the Ryder Cup by Its HandlesTiger Woods has Holes in His Golf Resume »

5 comments

Comment from: Dave Carpenter [Visitor]
I have a completely different opinion. Here is my column "Chili Dips":

The PGA of America could easily become the scapegoat should Team Europe successfully defend its Ryder Cup at The K Club in Kildare, Ireland.
Reeling from an embarrassing 18.5-9.5 shellacking in the 2004 trans-Atlantic shootout under the Stars and Stripes at Oakland Hills, PGA officials changed the way qualifying points are awarded. And they blew it.
Our new system puts a premium on current year performance; an attempt to field the hottest players to represent the Red, White and Blue. (They got that part right at least). But, points are only awarded for top-10 finishes, and points up for grabs in majors are basically twice those at stake in regular Tour events – a double-edged sword as it turned out.
For those non-Ryder Cup enthusiasts out there – if there are any – there are 12 spots on each team. The first ten are assigned based on points accumulated during the two-years between the biannual matches, with the remaining two team members picked by the team captains, who are Tom Lehman and Ian Woosnam.
The scramble to automatically qualify for Team USA ended at the PGA Championship. The new point system resulted in placing four Ryder Cup rookies on the team: Vaughn Taylor, J.J. Henry, Zach Johnson and Brett Wettrerich. Three of those first-timers had fewer than 100 career PGA Tour starts: Taylor (82), Henry (86) and Wetterich (91).
On the morning following Tiger Woods’ PGA triumph, Lehman named Stewart Cink and Scott Verplank as his wildcards. Cink was No. 12 on the final point list and Verplank ranked No. 20. Both have Ryder Cup experience. In picking Cink and Verplank, Lehman put the kybosh on Ryder Cup veterans Davis Love III (15) and Fred Couples (16).
Woosnam has two additional weeks to see who qualifies for the Euros and to make his at-large picks. Picking after Lehman is an advantage, to be sure.
That’s not the only advantage Woosnam has.
Comparing Lehman’s final top-10 to Woosnam’s hopefuls with two weeks remaining, the Euros average Official World Golf Ranking is 21.1, while the average for our guys is 28.1. Sure, we have Tiger (1), Phil (2) and Furyk (4), but we also have Taylor (57), Wetterich (61) and Henry (74). On the other hand, the Euro OWGR range is No. 10 (Luke Donald) down to No. 42 (Paul McGinely). And the only possible Euro rookies are Henrik Stenson (17) and Robert Karlsson (41).
Cink and Verplank do bring added depth to Team USA, but they actually lower our average OWGR to 29.5: Cink (39); Verplank (34).
If all stays the same on the other side of the pond, who does Woosnam have to choose from? Well, it’s a pretty impressive bunch.
Just outside the top-10 is Carl Pettersson. Although this would be his first Ryder Cup, he ranks No. 26 in the world. Next is four-time Ryder Cupper Darren Clarke, OWGR 21. Then there are veterans Lee Westwood (45) and Miguel Angel Jimenz (47). With all the possible permutations, no matter who Woosnam picks Team Europe will bring a much lower OWGR average to The K Club.
The bottom line is the new PGA Ryder Cup point system is seriously flawed, primarily because points are awarded only for top-10 finishes.
When foreign players place in the top-10 in PGA Tour events, they rob points from our guys. This is potentially most damaging in majors where points are doubled and the fields of international players are stronger. Of the 40 possible top-10s in the 2006 majors, only 16 were claimed by players eligible for Team USA and eight of those were spread among Tiger, Phil, Furyk and Chris DiMarco.
The reverse is true for regular Tour events with lower purses and less-than-star-studded fields, allowing Taylor, Henry and Wetterich to garner enough points early in the year to eventually qualify. Meanwhile, OWGR top-50 veterans like Verplank, Cink, Love, Kenny Perry, Couples, Tim Herron, Ben Crane and Bart Bryant were left hoping for at-large bids.
By contrast, they use common sense assigning Ryder Cup points to qualify for Team Europe. The first five spots are given to players with the highest OWGR. The next five are chosen based on how much money they earn on the European Tour.
There is a possible silver lining, however.
Even though the PGA has stacked the deck against us, we do have an intangible on our side. The K Club course – 7,370 yards/par-73 with five par-5s – is an Arnold Palmer design.
I’ve got my fingers crossed for a USA victory, but I am not holding my breath.
08/25/06 @ 15:53
Comment from: Ron Mon [Member] Email
Is not Darren Clarke already a captain's choice?
08/25/06 @ 15:59
Comment from: Shanks [Member] Email
Dave, if you look at a couple of my previous blogs on this, you'll see that we agree on the flawed points system. However, I'm now just looking at how the 12 guys are performing against their likely opponents. And it's favors the US team right now.

RM, there's only speculation on Clarke & the wild card. I'm guessing that Clarke opts out when Woosie asks him if he wants to play. Certainly understandable, and a crying shame.
08/25/06 @ 16:06
Comment from: Ghet Rheel [Visitor]
Man. I wish I could get all excited about the Ryder Cup the way Peter Alliss does, but I just can't fake it. If it is on TV and I happen to be at home I'll watch a few minutes of it... yawn - I would contrast that with the Majors where I plan my week around being available to see every shot televised.

Ryder Cup is a little like the NBA playoffs for me... If I catch the last few minutes of the fourth quarter, I haven't missed much. BTW, in the past, the TV presentation of Ryder Cup scoring has been abysmal.
08/26/06 @ 12:56
Comment from: Shanks [Member] Email
I haven't found any problems with network scoring summary at all. I think they do a real good job of keeping the audience up to date with the status of each match as well as the overall score. But, to be fair, I don't just turn it on at the end to see what the result was either.
08/28/06 @ 07:40

This post has 1 feedback awaiting moderation...

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.
PoorExcellent
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)

Simply select where you want to play, find a tee time deal, and golf now!

Dates: January 1, 2014 - December 31, 2014
Want an Arizona golf vacation without the hassle of lugging your clubs or paying to check them in at the airline? JW Marriott Scottsdale Camelback Inn Resort & Spa's "Just Bring Your Swing to Scottsdale" vacation package is just for you! Includes deluxe accommodations, unlimited golf and golf clubs and shoe rental.
Price range: $209