« Sad Stories on the PGA and Nationwide ToursThe Highs and Lows of Televised Golf Tournament Coverage »

6 comments

Comment from: Stacy [Visitor] Email
I agree that this weekend's PGA Tour event will be a compelling one.

Watching the lower level unfold with possibly one of these players becoming a stand-out next season is ultimately what the Tour is all about.
11/08/08 @ 11:00
Comment from: Shanks [Member] Email
Very interesting weekend. And next up will be the always excruciating Q-school.
11/10/08 @ 07:41
Comment from: Wendy (UK) [Visitor] Email
Taking another peek at "Tales from
Q School", I noticed that there was an argument that the Nationwide Tour should now "be the sole proving ground for the PGA Tour". I suspect you wouldn't miss the drama of the last round of Q School for the world, but what's your take on this argument?
11/15/08 @ 12:02
Comment from: Shanks [Member] Email
It's a bad argument. Anytime a contest is held over a longer period of time, the cream will rise to the top. So of course the Nationwide is a better test. But there is a need for Q-school. If it didn't exist, the Nationwide graduates would increase to approx. the top 50 money earners, while #126 on the PGA Tour would have no chance to get back the following year. Seems to me that #126 on the PGA Tour might be a stronger player than #50 on the Nationwide Tour.

Take the case of Hunter Mahan. In 2005 he finished at #131 but regained his card in Q-school. In 2006 he nearly won a Tour event and easily made the top 125. Then in 2007 he won his first event and nearly defends in 2008. On top of that he was a U.S. Ryder Cup star at Valhalla. Who knows what might have happened had he been forced to sit out a year in 2006.
11/17/08 @ 07:45
Comment from: Wendy (UK) [Visitor] Email
Ok - didn't need much cogitation to agree that No.126 on PGA Tour stronger than No.50 on Nationwide. (There was no argument put forward other than Q School providing unlikely and uplifting stories).

You simply couldn't resist throwing me the Hunter Mahan Ryder Cup googly though, could you?!
11/18/08 @ 14:14
Comment from: Shanks [Member] Email
Sorry about the Mahan blurb. I promise it was only because he best illustrated the point! But you know I love the drama of Q-school. And you're right, everybody involved has an interesting story to tell, whether they're on the way up in their career or down.
11/18/08 @ 14:47

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.
PoorExcellent
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)
Golf Itineraries

Simply select where you want to play, find a tee time deal, and golf now!

Dates: January 1, 2012 - May 27, 2012
Experience this new and exciting Tournament, The Brother Brother Invitational at St Andrews, is a team event for siblings to enjoy a weekend of golf and camaraderie in St Andrews the Home of Golf. This package offers brothers the perfect opportunity to play 4 rounds of great golf, have plenty of fun, experience the magic that is St Andrews as a location.
Price range: £1600